Author: mike | Date: April 11, 2007 | Please Comment!

Well here I am trying to get active.  Since October, 2006  I’ve been trying to meet with my Member of Parliament,  Lee Richardson, Conservative, Calgary Centre.  I finally got to see him April 04, 2007.   I decided to go there because the Conservative government had withdrawn from the Kyoto Accord.  Years earlier I took pride that the government of the day had signed on as a member only to discover much later that it was basically for P.R.  I was not pleased with the ‘made in Canada solution’ that Harpers Conservatives proposed and was tired of them always blaming the Liberals and their years of inaction.  I wanted the leadership that Harper promised.  That’s why I voted for the Conservatives in the last federal election.  Harper showed he was capable of doing the “tough thing” with the Income Trust.  That was a reversal of a campaign promise and was very unpopular with business and many individual Canadian investors but it was done none the less.   

In my initial discussions with Lee Richardson’s office I had referenced two reports I had recently viewed, the Fifth estates’ report “The Denial Game” and Al Gore’s “An Inconvenient Truth”.  The Denial Game explained how the American government under George W. Bush was handling the environmental issue and that the individual who produced this very effective plan of disinformation came to Canada to present it to members of the Conservative Party including Stephen Harper.  At the request of Mr. Richardson’s office staff I supplied copies of both programs for them to view. 

When I initially met with Lee Richardson , I note in hindsight, I didn’t receive the friendly hand shake he freely offered the businessman who was seen just before me.  Within minutes of sitting down with him I found myself challenging Lee on his conduct.  I pointed out he was rude, appeared angry and, in my opinion, was being very disrespectful.  He settled down and we continued.  When asked if he had viewed the material I had sent his office he informed me he hadn’t.  He guessed ”The Denial Game” was a C.B.C. production and said that automatically made it slanted and biased.  I found this a strange comment given it was the C.B.C. reports on lead levels in Tuna and the Sponsorship Affair, to name a few, that caused government officials to take action and both issues were covered nationally on all the news networks.  He told me he fell asleep watching “ An inconvenient Truth”, blaming the format it was presented in.  He went on to say he didn’t like Al Gore and likened him to Michael Moore.  He contended that Al Gore was not a scientist, fed upon the ignorance of people and was an alarmist.  I found his opinion of Al Gore very surprising as his assistant, Will, had informed me earlier that he had arranged for  2 tickets for Lee Richardson to see Al Gore when he came to Calgary for a speaking engagement at the Chamber of Commerce later in the month.  These tickets were hard to come by, it was sold out and that Will had to use some “contacts” to get them. 

When Lee Richardson began to show further disrespect for me I ended the meeting.  Earlier I was hoping I’d have enough questions to cover the 30 minute meeting but found I was ending it after less then 20 minutes.    I had also wanted to tour the office after visiting Lee to see if our politicians where taking on a leadership role and leading by example. I had earlier arranged for this tour with Will.  Did the office recycle their paper products, their used batteries and what did they do with their obsolete or worn office equipment/furniture?.  Lee stated that as I’d ended the meeting with him I would not be allowed to tour his office.  In short, I was ”kicked out” of the office.   

One Comment. Add yours!

  • Chris Goss
    3:55 pm on April 14th, 2007

    David you are so right, the Conservatives have lost sight of who founded this province, and that they wanted to leave the land to future generations, not damaged ecosystems. The other Lakes OSUM and the SRD mentioned are not comparable to Marie Lake, I was quoted three lakes as comparison and here are my findings on them:

    Gull Lake is a large, shallow lake that mixes completely during most of the summer, and temperature remains uniform from the surface to the bottom.  Marie Lake is not of uniform temperature top to bottom (Marie Lake is strongly thermally stratified).  Will the stratification be lost? Will the stratification cause ducting of the sound without diminishing the intensity?

    Travers reservoir is oligotrophic (I did not know what that meant so I looked it up ( refers to any environment which offers little to sustain life)), Marie lake is not. So this is not a valid comparison. 

    Lake Newell I could not even find on the Atlas of Alberta Lakes. But it is the largest Man Made Reservoir in Alberta.  So it is not a naturally occurring water body, so it will be hard to compare it to a water body with limited in and outflow, such as Marie Lake.   Also the slopes into the water and bottom sedimentary conditions will be different. 

    Here is what Lindy Weilgart (associate at Dalhousie University) had to say:

    “Probably even worse than in the ocean because fish would be more restricted and can’t get away. Seismic is known to harm fish, either by changing their behavior, causing them to leave the area, probably temporarily, but for weeks, or even deafen them if close and loud enough. There is a fairly extensive literature showing how catch rates plummet around seismic surveys. Depending on what the lake bottom looks like (whether hard rock, mud, or sand), the damage could be worse/better (rock would be the worst, mud best, probably). I don’t expect seismic to be less harmful in freshwater.”

    So the future of Marie Lake if siesmic is carried out does not look good.

    Yes the government needs to revise how they grant mineral rights and where, and consult with local land owners, before leasing them.

Leave a reply!